Toohey’s Butchery & Bistro

January 21, 2021

Toohey’s Butchery & Bistro

**As of May 2023, the restaurant at Toohey’s is not currently open, but the butchery is open Monday – Saturday from noon to 8:30 pm.**

Right across the street from Colleen’s, in the heart of Haiku, Toohey’s Butchery and Bistro is open for business at 824 Kokomo Road!  We’ve seen it at the Upcountry Farmer’s Market for some time, and we finally had a chance to try their food!  First, we’ll discuss what we ate at the Bistro.

824 Kokomo Road
Haiku, HI 96708
(808) 856-0311

toohey's Bistro

best Maui luaus


The Bistro

They’re being smart and starting out slow (they’ve been open less than 2 weeks).  We’re told they have live music on weekends in what will soon be the beer garden, but for now, it’s BYOB.

Toohey's Bistro and Butchery in Haiku, Maui

Their menu is limited to tacos (pork and beef) and cheeseburgers to start.  We tried both and were BLOWN AWAY!  The beef taco was my favorite.

Lahaina Gateway



The Butchery

Local, organic, gmo-free meats?  YES PLEASE!  After our meal, I dropped into the butchery (open 7 days a week 9-11.)  They had just gotten in a fresh pig from Malama Farms (we love David and Tina!)   They also had some really nice cuts of beef, but we went with the pork tenderloin.

Toohey's Butchery

We took it home, rolled it in herbs and spices, seared it in a pan and finished it in the oven.  It was DELICIOUS!  The best pork I’ve ever made, without a doubt.

Malama Farms Pork Tenderloin

There’s something to be said about local Maui farmers that care about their animals.  We’ll be back with another update with better photos soon.  ALOHA, and welcome to the neighborhood!


Before you pick up your butchery order make sure to visit Ace of Cups – a tarot and divination shop just steps from Toohey’s. This inviting storefront is stocked with witchy wonders: tarot and oracle decks, dream journals, smudge sticks, pendulums, crystals, live readings, and more!


Maui Restaurants


Pilina Restaurant Review

Pilina Restaurant Review

Pilina Maui in the Faimont Kealani expertly crafts unique cocktails using the freshest ingredients available in an ambiance you wont forget.

Ko Maui Brunch Review

Ko Maui Brunch Review

We went to the beautiful Fairmont Kea Lani in Wailea to check out the brunch at Kō Restaurant. Enjoy this Ko Maui review of our experience.

Macadangdang Maui Review

Macadangdang Maui Review

Macadangdang Maui Review. We spent a wonderful day on the West Side of Maui that finished at Macadangdang Maui in Kaanapali.


  1. nikhilananda

    ALOHA Toohey’s Butchery & Bistro …. congrats & welcome to the neighborhood; plan to stop by & check out Pat Simmons Jr. this thursday, 3 october; hope there is some healthy, non-murdered animal food to enjoy….. (y) mahalo…..


    When will menu be posted on website?

    • Dining Maui

      We headed over for the grand reopening yesterday, but they’re not quite ready. As soon as they get up and running, we’ll share a renewed review for everyone. Mahalo!


Submit a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

Get Free Maui eBook!

Sign up for our free monthly Maui newsletter, and we'll send you a 280+ page Maui ebook.

Maui Restaurant Reviews
Review Date
Reviewed Item
Toohey's Butchery & Bistro
Author Rating